Whether you are new to the espresso world or decide to upgrade from basic consumer espresso machine, Rancilo Silvia and Gaggia Classic will always be the right choice if your budget is between $700 and $1,000. The question now is how to decide which will suit you the most. Let me break the pro/con down for you so hopefully you will be able to decide at the of this article.
Physical Design:
The two physical machines being discussed are quite similar in appearance, with both having a retro look and similar features such as cup warming trays and rocker switches for power and brewing. However, there are a few differences worth noting.
- The water reservoir on the Gaggia Classic can be filled from the front as well as the top, which can be useful for those with low hanging cabinets.
- The metal drip tray on the Rancilo Silvia is nicer than the plastic one on the Gaggia Classic, but it has a strange design flaw: instead of being a deep tray, it is just a metal grate that reveals a shallow pan underneath. This reduces the capacity and makes it difficult to remove without spilling if it is close to full.
Gaggia wins (+1)
Build Quality:
- Overall, the Rancilo Silvia has higher quality construction in certain areas such as the portafilter handle, steam knob, and steam arm, which are all more durable compared to the Gaggia Classic.
- Additionally, the Rancilo Silvia is significantly heavier at 50% more than the Gaggia Classic, making it easier to lock in the portafilter without needing to hold the machine in place.
Rancilio wins (+1)
Performance:
In terms of espresso quality, both the Gaggia Classicand Rancilo Silvia machines perform similarly, with both having 58mm portafilters and effective group heads that produce consistent, high-quality espresso when paired with a good grinder. However, both machines require some temperature adjustments to ensure accurate temperature control, as neither have a PID.
- The Rancilo Silvia has a slight advantage due to its higher quality filter baskets, and also offers a more straightforward method for adjusting brew pressure.
- While the Gaggia Classicrequires some additional work to achieve the same result.
Rancilio wins (+1)
Thing to consider:
Before discussing the steaming abilities of these machines, it's important to note that the quality of the grinder used can greatly impact the final espresso product. If the cost of the Rancilo Silvia machine is already stretching your budget, it may be wiser to opt for the Gaggia Classic and invest in a higher quality grinder. In general, using a Gaggia Classic machine with a $700 grinder (like Eureka Mignon Specialita) will likely produce better espresso than a Rancilo Silvia with a $300 grinder (like Breville Smart Grinder).
Steaming Performance:
- The Rancilo Silvia has a 300ml boiler, which allows it to steam faster and for a longer period of time than the Gaggia's 100ml boiler.
- However, the transition between brewing and steaming takes longer on the Silvia, at 1.5 minutes compared to the Gaggia's 35 seconds.
- Both machines are capable of producing high quality microfoam for lattes, but the Rancilio's steam arm, which is on a ball joint, provides a higher quality steaming experience compared to the Gaggia's pivot arm which feels slightly cheap.
It's a draw (we would opt for Silivia if there is more than one coffee drinker).
Modification:
It is worth noting that both of these machines have a wide range of modifications available, including PIDs and shot timers. These modifications are popular among users and can enhance the performance of the machines beyond their price range. If you enjoy tinkering, you can further improve the already impressive performance of these machines.
Gaggia wins (+1) since there are a lot of resources available on the Internet (both technical instructions and mod equipment availability).
Final Words:
Thanks for reading this far but it is a draw unfortunately.
Ultimately, it comes down to your budget and whether or not you already own a quality espresso grinder. If the Rancilo Silvia is outside of your budget, it may be more beneficial to choose the Gaggia Classic Pro and allocate your funds towards a separate grinder.
However, if budget is not an issue, the Rancilo Silvia offers a more durable build and stronger steaming capabilities, albeit with a slower transition speed. Both of these machines are popular choices for a reason and will provide a strong foundation for your home espresso setup.
The Espresso Time
Adelaide Brisbane Melbourne Perth Sydney Tasmania